The Westing Game by Ellen Raskin (1978)
It surprised me this year to find a Newbery-winning title on each of the two book clubs I run. While the adults chose Rifles for Watie (1957, winner 1958), the younger folks chose The Westing Game (1978, winner 1979). Apart from Rifles, it’s been a while since I’ve read a winner, so I enjoyed the venture back into youth fiction.
Note: this post includes Amazon affiliate links.
Quick Summary of The Westing Game
The story opens with a mysterious maneuver to get sixteen different people to rent apartments in a new building called Sunset Towers on the Wisconsin banks of Lake Michigan. When the old man Westing is found murdered in his house on the hill above the apartments, the sixteen are summoned to a will-reading, during which they’re informed that someone in the room is the killer.
The group then discovers it’s up to them, in eight teams of two, to use the clues given to solve the crime and inherit Westing’s fortune and business. Young Turtle Wexler is the main protagonist through whom we watch the story unfold, and it’s her wits and nerve and chatting with others that help us feel like we’re solving the case alongside her.
My Kids Never Took to It
I recall trying to read this book aloud to my kids about three years ago, when they were aged 10 and 11. They didn’t want me reading past the first chapter! They hated the talk of haunted houses and corpses, and I totally get it.
Even reading this book now on my own, I can see what scared them so. Take this early passage, for example, which was probably the trigger:
Theo squatted next to the wheelchair. “Listen, Chris, I’ll tell you about that haunted castle on the hill.” His voice was soothing and hushed in mystery. “Somebody is up there, Chris, but nobody is there, just rich Mr. Westing, and he’s dead. Dead as a squashed June bug and rotting away on a moth-eaten Oriental rug. … And the worms are crawling in and out of the dead man’s skull, in and out of his ear holes, his nose holes, his mouth holes, in and out of all his holes”. (14)
That’s not an especially inviting passage for a kid to hear, which is why we began reading The 39 Clues instead. What a great choice that ended up being for us at the time!
A Newbery Winner Drowned Out by Its Own Genre
I felt like I had guessed the solution to the puzzle about halfway through the book, but of course, my ideas were stymied. That’s a good thing, knowing that Ellen Raskin strung me along. I normally don’t try solving mysteries while I read them, and that’s why.
While I enjoyed the creative riddle that is The Westing Game, however, I had some doubts about its popularity after finishing it. If the book hadn’t won the Newbery award nearly 50 years ago, I think it would have otherwise been a story totally lost to history. Not that it’s poorly written, of course, but because the puzzling-mystery genre for youth is so glutted these days, few books like this can enjoy relevancy past a single generation.
I find this is mainly true because single books tend to get overshadowed by series, which kids (and dads) love. Even within the series themselves, though, one installment eventually just feels like another after a while.
Don’t get me wrong: I love reading the massive series like The 39 Clues, A Series of Unfortunate Events, and The Mysterious Benedict Society. But it’s the very popularity and appeal of such series en masse that inadvertently wash away the excitement of shorter, one-off mysteries like this.
Conclusion
The Westing Game will not go down as my favorite Newbery book, and that’s fine. I’m confident that if I were ever to genuinely read through them all, I’d probably hate 40% of them. This number would likely rise, the newer the books get since several of the recent winners were selected more for their politically progressive content than for their artistic contributions to children’s literature (note, for example, the 2021 and 2023 winners).
This makes me curious, actually: Which awards organizations or recommendation lists do you consult when choosing books for your kids to read? Let me know in the comments!
©2026 E.T.
Want more writing like this? Get Elliot’s Weekly Digest.
