Erasing Hell: What God Said about Eternity, and the Things We’ve Made Up by Francis Chan and Preston Sprinkle (2011)
I’ve had this book on my shelf for years, but I’ve always sort of been afraid to read it. I blame some offhanded comment from someone at some point (that I clearly don’t remember) that rusted itself into my mind, suggesting that Francis Chan was off the deep end theologically in this book. For that reason, I kept avoiding it.
Note: this post includes Amazon affiliate links.
A Disagreement That Aroused My Curiosity
Hell has been a topic of discussion (and disagreement) in one of my circles lately, and I figured that if Francis Chan really were “off” theologically about Hell, then reading his book might at least help me better understand where my friends were coming from. Namely, a friend has been really pushing the idea of annihilationism, that unbelievers will go to a real Hell, but only for a time, and will eventually be punished out of existence. It’s a relatively foreign concept to me, yet since he comes at me with Scripture, I haven’t wanted simply to reject it out of hand.
Thus, on my recent trip to the States, I decided finally to rescue Erasing Hell from storage and read it. I’m glad I checked the blurbs in the front of the book when I did—praise from the likes of Randy Alcorn, Joni Eareckson Tada, and Tremper Longman. These blurbs encouraged me that, even if Chan were to say something controversial in this book, it likely wouldn’t be too heretical.
Quick Summary of Erasing Hell
Chan opens by attacking three brands of universalism, the belief that everyone eventually gets to Heaven. This includes pluralists (non-Christian) and both the hopeful and the dogmatic universalists. He attacks these false beliefs not merely from logic—after all, we likely all want to believe that no one will spend eternity in Hell!—but also from Scripture. He attacks their “biblical arguments” by expanding the context of their favorite go-to passages and proving that there truly is no second chance to believe following death.
He then spends three chapters to discuss: what first-century Jews believed about Hell, what Jesus taught about Hell, and what Jesus’ own followers said about Hell in the rest of the New Testament. Of particular interest to me in the Jewish-background chapter was Chan’s refuting the “Gehenna was a garbage dump” myth, an idea that Rob Bell promoted in his popular Universalist text Love Wins (2011, so clearly the instigator of Chan’s book as response!). It’s also an idea that I still hear preached regularly from the pulpit, but happens to be biblically inaccurate. For more on that, you should read pages 56-61.
From these studies, Chan concludes that Hell is a place of punishment after judgment; that it is described in imagery of fire and darkness, where people lament; and that ultimately Hell is a place of either annihilation or never-ending punishment. It’s that third portion I wanted to read more about.
He then writes Chapter 5 as a warning to readers who think they’ve secured their “fire insurance,” because they once prayed a prayer; and then Chapter 7 as a call for unbelievers to repent. His goal is not to scare or to cause doubt but to make this issue of such massive import that everyone considers their conduct to make sure the Holy Spirit dwells in the heart. As my pastor used to say, “Hell’s too serious to hang on ‘Hope so.'”
In his longest chapter (6: “What If God…?”), Chan grapples with the very difficult musings of Paul in Romans 9. But he combines all he’s written thus far in this beautiful conclusion:
As I have said all along, I don’t feel like believing in Hell. And yet I do. Maybe someday I will stand in complete agreement with Him, but for now I attribute the discrepancy to an underdeveloped sense of justice on my part. God is perfect. And I joyfully submit to a God whose ways are much, much higher than mine. (141)
So What Are the Punishments of Hell?
In seminary, I read the fantastic Counterpoints book, Four Views on Hell (1996), and came away from it more centrist than I had anticipated. I remember thinking that maybe I wasn’t as “fundamental” as I thought I was—or maybe I wasn’t enough of a literalist to be a good Baptist.
The problem wasn’t that I didn’t believe what I’d been taught in my Independent Fundamental Baptist upbringing, or that I no longer believed in a literal interpretation of Scripture! Instead, I finally felt comfortable saying that sometimes the Bible uses figurative language (like “fire” and “darkness”) to describe something inexplicably terrible and beyond our current comprehension.
- Is there fire in Hell? I don’t know, but if there isn’t, then the source of pain is worse than fire, but that’s the best human word Jesus could use to describe it.
- Is Hell really filled with darkness? I don’t know, but it’s a place of loneliness and absence from the Father, so what source of light could there possibly be?
Chan writes that Jesus agreed with the early Jewish understanding of Hell being a place of both fire and torment and that it is an eternal place absent of second chances. At the absolute least, these are all metaphors for unimaginable judgment and torment. Chan concludes:
While the passages examined in this book are clear about hell as a real place where the wicked will be tormented, the Bible does not seem to tell us exactly what that torment will entail. (155)
So Does Chan Believe in Annihilation?
Throughout the book, this was a constant question in my mind. After all, it’s why I came to it in the first place! It seems to me that, while Chan sides with the orthodox belief in eternal punishment, he’s also open to the idea of annihilationism.
Why? His dissection of the Greek words behind “everlasting punishment” (aionios kolasis) hasn’t fully convinced him that this means eternal torment without end. My problem with this, of course, is that eternal torment in Scripture is often contrasted to eternal life; so if judgment isn’t really eternal, then why should I believe that life is?
If you want to understand more about his reasoning, I’d send you to Chapter 3 of this book.
Conclusion
At only 7 brief chapters, this book is far shorter than it looks. In fact, the endnotes take up about 35% of the pages and a free chapter of Forgotten God takes up another 10%.
Overall, this was a healthy recap of a very sobering subject, one that I need to be reminded of regularly, lest I get caught in the trap of thinking that death is just a bad thing that happens to everyone eventually. It’s far worse than that. While we believers might have a reason for hope, the majority of souls on this planet do not—and when they die, they will never have a second chance to remedy their torment. That’s horrendous news that can only be fixed with the Good News.
But when I think of that Good News, I realize that merely linking to it in a post few people will ever read is not enough. Romans 10:13-17 tells me what is—and oh! may I act on this today:
For “everyone who calls on the name of the Lord will be saved.”
How then will they call on him in whom they have not believed? And how are they to believe in him of whom they have never heard? And how are they to hear without someone preaching? And how are they to preach unless they are sent? As it is written, “How beautiful are the feet of those who preach the good news!” But they have not all obeyed the gospel. For Isaiah says, “Lord, who has believed what he has heard from us?” So faith comes from hearing, and hearing through the word of Christ.
©2026 E.T.
Want more writing like this? Get Elliot’s Weekly Digest.
