Logan’s Word by Donald L. Robertson (2014)

This past summer, I decided it was time to start reading something that’s never quite appealed to me: the Western novel.

Why had I been against the idea of Westerns? Unfairly, I’d assumed that, because they’d all follow the same tropes of rustlers and shootouts and Indians, they wouldn’t be interesting. The problem is, this idea of tropes is true of any genre:

  • Fantasies with their magic and strange creatures and hero’s journeys;
  • Spy Thrillers with their rogue agents, hellbent villains, and torture;
  • Courtroom Dramas with their underdog lawyer, secret antagonists, and surprise sources of evidence; etc.

Whatever I was harboring against Westerns, I obviously didn’t know what I was talking about. Beyond providing a good yarn, Westerns exist to boost our vision of masculinity, courage, sacrifice, and loyalty. That’s what we find in most Louis L’Amour novels, it’s present in Zane Grey, and it’s what I was hoping for in this, my first taste of Donald L. Robertson. He delivers in spades.

Quick Summary of Logan’s Word

The book opens on the Civil War battlefield of the Shenandoah Valley, with young Rory Nance dying in the arms of Major Josh Logan. With his dying breath, Rory asks Josh to share the news of his death with his parents in Texas, and despite his commitment to start a ranch in Colorado after the War, Logan gives his word.

It’s three whole years later, in 1867, when Logan’s finally able to keep that word and share the sad news with Rory’s family. Before he moves on from Texas, though, Josh decides to help Mr. Nance run his ranch for a bit and figure out who’s been rustling his cattle and why.

The book is filled with some rough characters, some real danger to Josh, and a touch of romance. There’s not much mystery, but it definitely has the requisite masculinity, courage, sacrifice, and loyalty.

Elements I Appreciated

A large part of this book deals with a shameless attack against one character and his subsequent set of injuries, as he’s shot in the head and dragged by horse over rocks and through a thicket of prickly-pears. I really enjoyed this whole portion of the book, because the character didn’t just miraculously overcome his injuries by the next chapter. Instead, he took time to find help, and the injuries took time to heal. This whole process seemed way more realistic than lagging, which reminded me of Jack DeWitt’s exquisite Man in the Wilderness or (at least in style) of Lionel Davidson’s Kolymsky Heights.

Another thing I appreciated was the book’s cleanliness. Josh doesn’t drink or smoke, though whiskey seems always present, and I don’t recall a single cuss word throughout. Other authors could learn from a writer like this who proves that language isn’t necessary for a good story!

I read this book in the midst of my attempts to read Lonesome Dove, and while the two novels are similar in style, setting, and plot, they are worlds apart in content. Lonesome Dove is all about sex, whores, and broken marriages, just in a Western setting. Coming back to Logan’s Word was like a breath of fresh air. It still has the cattle rustling, conversations, and cowboys, but it’s clean. It was refreshing.

Conclusion

This is my first try reading Donald L. Robertson, and I was pleasantly entertained. As far as I know, this is Book 1 of 4 in the Logan Family Western Series, so I look forward to continuing this saga to find out where Josh and all them end up. The closing line of this first book also piques the interest and makes me want to continue, so I’m happy for that.

©2026 E.T.

Want more writing like this? Get Elliot’s Weekly Digest.

This entry was posted in Fiction - Secular and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

What do you think?