The Great Imposter by Robert Crichton (1959)

The Amazing Career of the Most Spectacular Imposter of Modern Times

I read a lot, and a quick perusal of my site will tell you that my reading tastes tend to be eclectic. I’ve read some true crime in the past (like A Death in Belmont by Sebastian Junger and A Father’s Story by Lionel Dahmer), but it’s absolutely not my kind of genre. Still, sometimes a book will come out of left field and strike my fancy, and that’s exactly what’s happened with this book.

It’d be no exaggeration for me to say that The Great Imposter by Robert Crichton is probably the best book I’ve read so far this year. I’m not saying it’s the best-written necessarily—it’s a bit simplistic, as if it were developed as a magazine serial—but it’s absolutely the most fascinating and the most don’t-want-to-put-downable thus far (I’m sure Pulitzer has a category for that).

This non-fiction account follows the life and wayward times of one Fred Demara, a man whose boredom too often tempted him into pursuing jobs for which he was not qualified with credentials that weren’t his and under the names of men he’d met along life’s way. While this scenario sounds incredibly close to that of Frank Abagnale of the book (and film) Catch Me If You Can, Demara actually predated Abagnale by several decades and pursued different lines of work.

Demara’s primary passion had been the Catholic Church. Upon entering several orders and being summarily dismissed for not quite fitting in, Demara realized that if he could swipe some of the bishops’ letterhead and reapply to new orders under different names, he could always restart his adventures and hope for a better outcome. His earliest attempts at such deception, however, were sloppy and quickly detected, but each step of the way he honed his skills, emboldened his lies, and improved his chances at sneaking in (and out of) positions whenever he saw fit.

Demara’s adventures took him from Catholic orders and into the U.S. military in WWII from which he eventually deserted, a crime that would normally have required the death penalty, if Demara the impromptu lawyer weren’t on the case. From there he entered the field of psychology with a PhD that he didn’t quite earn but knew he could eventually learn to deserve, a degree he used to start a college of philosophy (that at the time of publication was still running—and apparently has since became Walsh University in Canton, OH). Demara wasn’t exempt from paying for his crimes along the way, serving 18 months in jail for his desertion, being fined for some of his impostering, and eventually being hunted by detectives and the Law (an aspect of the story that gets very little attention).

Once “reformed,” Demara went back to his hometown to live a life of honesty but soon became bored once more, and so enlisted in the Canadian Navy during the Korean War, not as a soldier but as a medical doctor. This role (what Demara himself calls “one of my best”) was certainly the most fascinating identity thus far, finding himself as the chief medical officer aboard a ship in the seas of Japan, performing normal doctoral duties as well as some emergency surgeries. Eventually dubbed “the miracle doctor,” Demara got his face (and false name/credentials) published in papers across Canada where his role as impostor was revealed and he was once more outed and forced back into his own miserable life and hometown. Falling into alcoholism, Demara then made his way to Texas where, through contacts he made in AA, he landed a job as prison guard and within a month very nearly becomes a full-time warden!

The exploits of this man are legendary, though now 60 years later, they’ve been very nearly forgotten. According to IMDB, the ’90s TV show The Pretender was loosely based on his life, and in 1960, Tony Curtis starred in The Great Imposter, a highly fictionalized version of Demara’s experiences. I couldn’t get enough of this story and am super glad to have come across this little book.

A number of comments between Fred and the author stuck out to me as I read, but really it was Demara’s philosophy of life that was most striking. Living with an almost pathological belief that “the ends justify the means,” Demara saw little wrong in stealing the identities of others, so long as he was doing so to benefit the world and those around him. His philosophy: Why waste all that time learning and earning credentials when I can do good now with false credentials and learn-and-earn along the way? (64) It’s a good question!

Also, while Demara’s departure from his roles were often sudden, his morphing into new ones took a great deal of planning and “figuring” (65), improving in the intricacies of detail as the years went on. Perhaps my favorite line about his confidence in these roles came later: “A man with a good mind who trusts it can learn anything he needs to know in a few months.” (94)

Although in the lower times of life Demara recognized himself to be a terrible person, he also cared a great deal about others. In the times between identities when he used his own name, he often worked in organizations for children with special needs, and he truly cared to make the lives of those around more pleasant and joyful. About the end of his first military career in which he faked a suicide, Demara later sated: “My only regret was that I had but two or three lives to give for my country.” (72) He died in 1982, and far as I can tell, not in prison.

This was a fascinating book, and I highly recommend it. I’m planning to read Catch Me If You Can soon, so it will be fun to see how the two compare.

©2022 E.T.

Want more writing like this? Get Elliot’s Weekly Digest.

This entry was posted in Nonfiction - Secular and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

What do you think?