
Get it in hardcover
Get it on Kindle
Get it on Audible
(paid links)
I realize that, of late, I’ve only posted reviews of novels! This post falls right in line with that trend, but of course that doesn’t mean I’m reading nothing but fiction. As a student, I’ve got my nose deep into journal articles and dissertations, so the novel has lately been my true escape—and I appreciate the break.
At some point in the past, I met this author, a long-time pastor of a Baptist Church in Western Wisconsin. I picked up this novel especially because of that small connection and because he sets the book in my own stomping grounds of Southwest Wisconsin, though during the 1950s and ’60s, a time I don’t quite recall.
The story is narrated by the daughter of a man who recently died, a daughter who shares her father’s spiritual biography and how his conversion during the Korean War eventually turned to the salvation of many within his family. Terpstra mentions at some point that the plot of this family’s history is a mishmash of true-life anecdotes he’s heard over the years as a pastor, and I suppose his choice to use a female narrator allows distance from people thinking this was his own father’s story.
Because of Terpstra’s long experience as a Baptist preacher in Wisconsin, one thread that sort of runs throughout the book is a commentary against Lutheranism, at least the Lutheranism that holds to pedobaptism, the idea that babies and infants receive God’s grace and salvation through an act of their parents, without faith or repentance on the part of the child.
Dad, in this book, was such a baby who grew up knowing he was a Christian, not because he had ever put his faith and trust in the work of Christ or repented from his sins, but because he put his faith and trust in his baptism and the words of his parents. Thus, throughout the book, Dad finds himself in turmoil, thinking he’s a Christian, but bearing no fruit and feeling no confidence in the Lord. It’s not until he’s wounded on the battlefield that he realizes he’s not yet prepared for the afterlife, and he asks a chaplain to show him the Truth.
Dad eventually trusts the Gospel of Christ as it’s laid out in Scripture (as opposed to any particular church tradition), repents, and gives his life to the Lord. From here on out, he seeks to be a light to his family, sharing the truths of Scripture whenever he’s able.
Perhaps my favorite portion of the book was the final collection of anecdotes in Chapters 19-21 about Dad’s sister, Aunt Annabelle, and her struggles with singleness and broken friendships. I don’t know why these dramatic little romances were more memorable to me than Dad’s whole story, but they really flowed and were just a joy to read.
Terpstra fills this book with Scripture and preaching, which is funny to me, because I recently wrote a review in which sort of bashed “preachiness” in Christian novels! In that post, I did leave the caveat that I’m not a fan of it unless that’s the book’s main goal. Judging by this book’s title (and the fact that the author is himself a preacher), I think I’m safe in assuming that preaching was his goal. He certainly does well with it!
Before cracking open Insufficient Faith, I wasn’t quite sure what quality of writing I might find inside. Terpstra is, as far as I can tell, a new writer and an untested author, yet I was immediately struck by the natural flow of his writing and was impressed by the clear, sharing-some-recollections style of writing. The only critique I have is that occasionally the narrator recalls more detail than she probably ought, given the fact that she wasn’t really present (at least cognitively) for any of it. She’s only relating the stories that her parents and aunt had shared with her over the years. Thus, it may have been more realistic (and less distracting, at least for me) to have tagged some of those lengthy quotations with, “Dad said something like…” That may be a nitpicky comment, but it came to mind often enough as I read that I thought it important to mention.
This was an enjoyable read for me and a good reminder of the importance of backing up one’s beliefs with Truth, of memorizing Scripture and using it, especially when it comes to something as important as one’s relationship with God. Likely, very few unchurched folks will ever pick up this book and believe the Gospel, but pagans aren’t Terpstra’s target audience. Instead, his prayer is that more church folks will read it and, if necessary, recognize the shallowness of their own faith or the sandy foundation of their supposed salvation. He hopes that those who have trusted in baptism or confirmation or church attendance or their family’s testimony for their eternal salvation will recognize the insufficiency of such faith and put their trust finally in the work of Christ alone.
This book is a lengthy Gospel tract and a good one at that. I happily recommend it.
©2021 E.T.
Want more writing like this? Get Elliot’s Weekly Digest.